“To brine or not to brine a turkey for Thanksgiving”, that is the question. Whether ’tis nobler to opt for a wet brine or a dry brine comes down to a matter of personal opinion, and culinary enthusiasts hold strong ones, including this one! While this debate may feel timeless, it is actually a relatively modern topic that has gained widespread attention only over the past three decades.
Thirty years ago, home cooks rarely practiced wet-brining for holiday turkeys. The technique began gaining real momentum in the late 1990s and early 2000s, driven by prominent food coverage in The New York Times and The San Francisco Chronicle, as well as influential chefs like Alice Waters of Chez Panisse.
Modern culinary techniques and food science show that soaking a bird in gallons of wet brine is not necessary for achieving peak tenderness and flavor. Wet brining traditionally relies on a ratio of 1 cup of kosher salt per gallon of water; while adding sugar can enhance browning, aromatics in the solution rarely penetrate the meat, leaving most of their flavor behind in the liquid. Furthermore, wet brining requires substantial refrigerator space, creates a messy preparation, and risks turning the meat spongy while leaving the skin soft instead of crisp. Today, far superior results are achieved through two simple practices: spatchcocking (butterflying) to ensure fast, uniform cooking and or dry brining.
Pre-salting meat (dry-brining) is a centuries-old technique originally developed to preserve food long before the invention of modern refrigeration. While the exact term "dry brine" did not gain widespread popularity in culinary circles until around 2011, the approach itself was famously popularized by the legendary chef and food author the late Judy Rodgers. She detailed the process in The Zuni Cafe Cookbook, published in 2002. If you have ever sampled the food at San Francisco’s Zuni Cafe or made Judy’s celebrated Zuni Roast Chicken with Bread Salad, you know first hand how remarkable the results of this method are and exactly why I have never turned back when choosing between dry and wet brining.
What is dry brining and why does it make a turkey or chicken or any meat that it is applied to better? In. My. Opinion. Dry brining a turkey involves rubbing the bird with kosher salt (about 1 tablespoon per 4 pounds). Sprinkling coarse salt on raw meat triggers osmosis, drawing water to the surface to dissolve the salt into a concentrated brine. Over time, diffusion draws this brine deep into the muscle tissue, seasoning the meat and denaturing proteins so they retain moisture during cooking. Resting the meat uncovered in the refrigerator for at least 24 hours (and up to 72 hours) dries the exterior, which is key for creating a crispy skin on poultry or rich crust on steak. Pairing dry brining with accurate temperature checks using a modern instant-read thermometer ensures crisp skin and succulent, perfectly cooked meat every time. Aim to pull the breast meat around 155° F to 160° F, and target about 175° F to 180° F for the thighs. In my experience, turkey’s dark meat benefits from a slightly higher internal temperature than chicken to properly break down collagen into a silky texture. Finally, allow the bird to rest for at least 30 minutes before carving (“rest” assured, it will still be piping hot!).
This Thanksgiving season brings endless possibilities for preparing your turkey, whether you favor the deep moisture-infusion of a wet brine, the flavor-concentrating results of a dry brine, or prefer to forego brining entirely. You might opt to spatchcock your bird for fast, even cooking on the Echo or Hybrid Fire Grill, fire roast it to crisp perfection on the Hybrid or Gaucho rotisserie, slow-smoke it over natural wood coals in the Gravity Smoker, or forego the whole bird and choose boneless breast and thigh roasts for an intimate gathering.
Whichever culinary path you explore this year, we hope you take time to reflect on what matters most. While Thanksgiving is one of our country's finest culinary traditions and we all strive for an extraordinary feast, the true spirit of the holiday comes from cherishing moments with family and friends, giving thanks for good health and celebrating the year's blessings. Everyone at Kalamazoo deeply appreciates your passion and support and we wish you and your loved ones a warm, joyful, and delicious holiday!
Tips to Ensure a Perfectly Cooked Turkey
Size Matters
Aim for 12 to 15 pounds for ideal moisture and even cooking. Turkeys over 18–20 pounds take much longer to cook, causing outer layers and dark meat to dry out before the deep center breast reaches safe temperatures.
For groups of 16 or larger, opt for two smaller birds (10–12 lbs each) or supplement with a bone-in breast. Smaller turkeys thaw faster, fit ovens better, cook more evenly, and yield double the drumsticks and crispy skin.
Thawing
Allow enough time to thaw your turkey safely in the refrigerator. In my recipe testing at the Kalamazoo culinary center, a 12-lb turkey took 4 days to thaw completely. Keep it in its original packaging on a baking sheet on the bottom shelf to catch any leaks. Remember that you can’t begin brining your turkey until it has completely thawed.
Brining
If you’re wet brining your turkey:
After brining, pat dry with paper towels. Place turkey breast-side up on a flat wire rack set over a rimmed baking sheet and refrigerate, uncovered, 8 to 24 hours. Air drying your turkey removes moisture from the exterior, producing very crisp skin. Proceed with your recipe.
If you’re salting (dry brining) your turkey:
After applying salt, place turkey, breast-side up, on a flat wire rack set over a rimmed baking sheet. Refrigerate, uncovered, for 24 to 72 hours. Proceed with your recipe.
Trussing
Knowing how to truss the bird properly will go a long way in yielding an evenly cooked, golden-brown turkey. If the bird isn’t trussed correctly you can end up with burnt wings and less than impressive results. Check out our step-by-step guide to trussing a rotisserie turkey.
Is it Done?
Don’t depend on that little pop-up thermometer that comes pre-inserted into the turkey; they’re unreliable and can lead to underdone or overcooked birds. The most accurate way to gauge the doneness of a turkey is to take its temperature with an instant read thermometer.
Breast Doneness
Insert the thermometer from the neck end, holding it parallel to the bird. (Avoid hitting the bone, which can give an inaccurate reading.) It should register around 155-160 °F. Remember that the temperature will increase a good 10 °F as the turkey rests before carving.
Thigh Doneness
Insert the thermometer at an angle into the area between the drumstick and breast away from the bone. It should register at least 175 °F but I prefer 180 °F for turkey to break down tough connective tissues (collagen) and render intramuscular fat, which turns tough, chewy meat into tender, juicy meat.
Resting/Carving
First, let the bird rest for roughly 30 minutes, very loosely tented with foil to preserve its deeply browned, crispy skin. This resting period allows the juices to reabsorb into the meat rather than spilling across your cutting board. Additionally, account for carryover cooking: after the turkey is removed from the oven, its internal temperature continues to rise by at least 10° F, bringing it to a safe minimum temperature and perfect doneness without drying out the outer layers of the breast.
Instead of attempting to carve the Thanksgiving turkey at the table before an eager group of guests, I recommend taking care of this messy task in the quiet, controlled setting of your kitchen. Set up a large carved-groove cutting board to collect any runaway juices, grab a freshly sharpened chef's knife, and get started. For a clear, professional approach to breaking down the turkey breast, drumsticks, and thighs, check out this step-by-step guide from America’s Test Kitchen.






